Cold Email

Influencer Cold Email Tactics: Boost Your Open Rate

Learn the art of influencer cold emailing with tips on crafting personalized, concise messages with powerful CTAs, all designed to captivate, convey your unique value, and encourage a positive response.

Jan 23, 2024

Woman using her laptop boosting open rate

Ever wondered how influencers seem to effortlessly snag those brand deals? It's all about mastering the art of the cold email. Think of it as your digital handshake, your first step into a world of potential collaborations.

The Power of Cold Emails for Influencers

Imagine you're about to play a high-stakes poker game, and the right cold email is that ace you have up your sleeve. It's a strategic move you've got to make count. Cold emails are your secret weapon to unlocking doors that might seem closed at first glance. You're not just pitching; you're initiating a valuable conversation, and it begins with a winning opener.

When it comes to cold emails, there's a delicate science behind it. Unlike spam, which is like tossing flyers into a gust of wind, a crafted cold email is a targeted invitation. It requires finesse and personal touch. Remember, you're not trying to sell a brand on the spot. You're showing them why a partnership with you is a conversation worth having.

Here's a big misconception: cold emailing is only about numbers. Cast a wide net, and you're bound to catch something, right? Well, not quite. You're aiming for quality over quantity. Spamming inboxes is like shouting into the void. Instead, tailor your messages. It makes all the difference. You wouldn't wear a swimsuit to a job interview, and in the same vein, you shouldn't send a generic email when you're aiming to impress.

Let's break down some tangible tips for crafting your approach:

  • Research the brand thoroughly.

  • Tailor your message to reflect the brand's values.

  • Highlight what you can offer, not just what you're seeking.

  • Use a subject line that stands out but remains genuine.

Common slip-ups include overlooking the tone of your email. You're not drafting a legal document, so loosening up a bit can work wonders. Picture the brand manager on the receiving end; they've seen hundreds of emails, and yours has to be the breath of fresh air that perks up their day.

What about the structure of your email? Gather your thoughts like you'd pack a suitcase. Start with the essentials, then layer in personality and details that snap everything into focus. The goal is to end your email without questions left unanswered, except for "When can we start?"

Crafting an Attention-Grabbing Subject Line

Imagine your subject line as the headline of your personal advertisement. It has to be snappy and specific enough to stand out in a cluttered inbox. Think of it as a first impression—often, it’s your one shot at catching a brand’s attention.

The common trap influencers fall into is using generic subject lines like “Collaboration Opportunity” or Love Your Brand!”. These are about as exciting as plain oatmeal. Now picture this: would you open an email titled “5 Unique Ways I Can Amplify Your Brand’s Message”? It’s targeted, it promises value, and it sparks curiosity. That’s what wins in the inbox race.

Here’s an everyday comparison: If you’re fishing for a big catch, you don’t use stale bait. Similarly, the subject line is your bait in the sea of emails, and you want it to be fresh and enticing.

Consider these practical tips for getting it right:

  • Tailor to the Brand: Like a bespoke suit, custom-fit your subject line to the brand's image.

  • Use Their Language: If they’re casual and quirky, be casual and quirky. If they're sophisticated, match that in your tone.

  • Create a Sense of Urgency: But avoid sounding like clickbait. “Limited Offer: Your Product, My Engagement Boost” creates urgency without the sleaze.

  • Question Hooks: Pose an intriguing question. “Ever Seen Your Product Featured in an Extreme Sport?” piques interest because it's unexpected.

Incorporate the practice of A/B testing—sending out two different subject lines to a small portion of your audience to see which performs better. This technique guides you in shaping your future campaigns.

A method less discussed is the use of emojis — but cautiously. An emoji can add personality and stand out, but too many can look unprofessional.

Remember, the key to mastering cold emails is experimentation. Try different techniques and analyze the open rates. Your subject line is a constant work in progress, sculpted by the responses it receives. Adjust, refine, and perfect it as you collect data on what resonates with your intended brand partners.

Personalizing Your Cold Email for Maximum Impact

Imagine stepping into a room full of strangers and striking a conversation. You wouldn’t speak to a laid-back artist the same way you’d talk to a corporate CEO, right? Your approach to personalizing cold emails should be the same – custom-tailored, just like a suit fitted for a special occasion.

Tailor Your Greeting, and don’t rely on generic salutations like Dear Sir/Madam. A little research can go a long way; use the recipient’s name, and if possible, comment on a recent achievement or mention common connections. This shows that you're not just another face in the crowd – you're someone who’s done their homework.

Common mistake alert – don't overdo it. You’re reaching out professionally, not writing a fan letter. Balance is key; ensure your email is friendly yet professional, personalized yet concise.

When talking techniques, the 'hook and reel' method works wonders. Start with something attention-grabbing (the hook), like a shared interest or a compelling fact about your work. Then, smoothly transition into why you're reaching out (the reel). It’s like fishing – you need both the right bait and technique to catch a fish.

As for variations, some influencers swear by video messages while others prefer text. Choose what aligns with your brand and the recipient's preferences. For a conservative brand, stick to text. If the brand is more modern, a creative video could set you apart.

Incorporating Relevant Case Studies or Statistics shows you’re serious. Think of it as bringing a portfolio to an interview. It gives the other party something tangible to assess your potential partnership on.

And as for the best routes to take, always, always proofread your email. It's like checking your teeth for spinach before a date. Sending an email with typos is the virtual equivalent of that spinach – it's all they'll remember.

Keep these points in your quiver, and you’ll be hitting the bull's-eye with your personalized cold emails.

The Art of Writing a Compelling Introduction

When you're reaching out cold, your email is one unknown message in a sea of hundreds. Imagine it's like trying to catch someone's attention in a crowded room—you've got to be clear, engaging, and memorable. Your intro is your first impression, and you want it to pop.

Think of your introduction as a handshake; firm, confident, and pleasant. You'll want to kick off with a strong subject line, as it's the make-or-break moment where recipients decide whether to open the email or not. Craft something that's both compelling and relevant—like mentioning a mutual connection or an admired project of theirs.

Now let's talk the opening line. The first sentence of your email has to hook your reader. Arouse curiosity or state something that resonates with their interests or challenges. Tailor this line specifically to the person you're contacting. It shows you've done your homework, and you're not just blasting out a template to anyone with an email address.

There's a common pitfall here: starting off by talking about yourself. It's tempting to dive right into who you are and why you're awesome but hold that thought. First, you need to build a connection and show that you understand the recipient's world.

Let's also dispel a myth—longer is not better. Keep your intro crisp and to the point. People are busy, and you're asking for a slice of their time. Get to the point quickly but warmly.

One approach is to ask a question tied to their business or interests. Questions invite answers, and psychologically, they're hard to ignore. This technique opens a door for dialogue.

And remember, personalizing is not just about using the recipient's name. It's about tapping into what excites them or problems they might want solved. Did they post about a recent challenge on LinkedIn? Reference it. Is there a news article about a success they've had? Congratulate them sincerely.

  • Grab attention with a subject line that speaks to their interests.

  • Personalize your opening to show genuine interest and research.

  • Be concise—deliver your message without unnecessary fluff.

  • Ask a question to engage them and encourage a response.

  • Focus on the recipient, not yourself, to build a rapport.

Showcasing Your Value Proposition

Picture this: You've just met someone who could change the game for you. You wouldn't start off by bragging about your accolades. Instead, you'd find common ground, then subtly weave in what you do best. That's your value proposition in a cold email. It's the secret sauce that makes a stranger think, this person can really help me out.

Ever stumbled upon an email that made you wonder, What's in it for me? Chances are, the sender forgot to highlight their value proposition, a common slip-up. Here's the deal: You have to show your recipient exactly how they'll benefit from your influence.

Crafting Your Unique Offer

  • Identify Your Edge: What sets you apart from others? Maybe it's your innovative approach or your engaging community. Pin this down first.

  • Solve a Problem: Think about the challenges your recipient might face and outline how your skills can tackle these head-on.

  • Be Specific: Vague promises don't cut it. If you've increased engagement by 30% for a previous collaboration, mention it!

You may think that listing out your achievements is enough, but remember the age-old saying, Show, don't tell. Instead of just stating your followers' numbers, explain how your audience engagement can lead to tangible results for your prospective collaborator.

Avoiding Over-promising

Nobody likes to feel duped. It's tempting to oversell your influence but resist the urge. Over-promising can backfire if you can't deliver. Always stick to the facts and let your genuine capabilities do the talking.

Timing Is Everything

Knowing when to showcase your value makes a huge difference. Don't jump the gun in the first sentence, ease into it. Once you have their attention, present your proposition clearly and compellingly.

Picture the perfect pitch as a cup of your favorite coffee. It’s not just about the quality of the beans (your skills) but how you brew it (your pitch). You wouldn’t enjoy a cup of coffee served lukewarm, and similarly, your value proposition needs to be delivered just right — warm, strong, and invigorating.

Establishing Credibility and Social Proof

When you’re reaching out as an influencer, establishing credibility is like showing your hand in a game of poker; you’ve got to have the right cards. Think of your experience and past collaborations as the royal flush in your cold email outreach strategy. But how do you convey this effectively?

First up, social proof: this is like the trusted friend who vouches for you at a party. Here’s how to use it to your advantage:

  • Feature logos of brands you've worked with if you’ve partnered with recognizable names.

  • Include testimonials or quotes from past clients that highlight your success.

  • Mention numbers that stand out, like a significant increase in followers or engagement rates after your campaigns.

In your email, address potential pain points with a touch of authority. It’s about saying ‘I’ve been there, I’ve done that, and I can help you too’. Always remember not to sound boastful; it's a fine line between confidence and arrogance.

Common missteps include over-relying on one’s follower count or content quality without backing it up. It's not just about what you have done; it's about how it made a difference. Did your campaign drive sales, or did it boost the brand’s visibility in a tough market? That's what businesses care about.

Different approaches suit different brands. A tech startup might value your innovative content creation, while a fashion brand could be looking for your trendsetting influence. Tailor your pitch to address the unique needs of the company you’re emailing.

Lastly, let’s talk about incorporating these practices. Start by creating a personalized, compelling narrative around your social proof. Draft a canvas where your expertise colors outside the lines and solves their specific issues. Use a clear, friendly tone and remember you’re solving a puzzle for them, not just selling a service.

Keep these tips in mind, and you’ll not only pique interest but also build a foundation of trust—vital for any influencer looking to secure new partnerships through cold emails.

Call to Action: How to Make Brands Say Yes

Crafting the perfect call to action (CTA) in your cold email can sometimes feel like you're trying to hit a bullseye in darts—it takes precision, practice, and a bit of finesse. Your CTA is essentially your pitch's closing argument; it's where you compel the brand to take the leap with you.

Think of your CTA as a handshake – it's not just a sign-off but an invitation for a connection. Here's how you can extend your hand confidently:

  • Use action-oriented language that's direct but not pushy. Instead of saying Would you like to... try Let's discuss... to create a sense of collaboration.

  • Make it as easy as possible for them to say yes. Offer to set up a call or meeting at their convenience.

  • Stand out by being explicit about the next steps. A CTA like Reply to schedule a 15-minute call this week is clear and specific.

Onto some common pitfalls. You might think making your CTA open-ended, like Feel free to reach out if interested, gives the recipient breathing room. In reality, it passes the decision-making burden to them, which is a no-go.

Correct this by being concrete in your ask. Instead of pushing the ball into their court, gently toss it – guide them on what to do next without being overbearing.

And here's a little-known trick: align your CTA with the recipient's objectives. If they're focused on boosting sales, propose a collaboration that speaks directly to sales growth. It shows you've done your homework and that your goals are in sync with theirs.

As for techniques, timing is key. If you're emailing during a busy season, acknowledge it, and be concise. Try saying, I know the holiday rush is here, so I'll keep this brief. It tells them you respect their time and primes them for your CTA.

  • Ensure your call to action is visible and stands out. You could use bold text or a separate line to draw attention.

  • Personalize your CTA based on the recipient's brand, recent achievements, or challenges. It might look like, Congrats on the recent award! Let’s talk about how we can bring that success to your new line.

Follow-Up: The Key to Success

When you've sent a cold email, it's like planting a seed in a garden. Just as a seed needs water and sunlight to grow, your email needs a follow-up to truly take root in the mind of your recipient. Following up is essential because it shows persistence, reminds the recipient of your initial message, and often makes the difference between a response and your email being lost in the digital wilderness.

Sending a Single Follow-Up can increase reply rates by over 40% according to studies. With those odds, it's clear that one simple reminder could be all that stands between you and success.

Here's the deal, most folks think sending one email is enough—but that's a common mistake. People are busy, and your first email is easily buried under an avalanche of others. So don’t just wait around; plan to send at least one follow-up email about three to five days after your initial message.

Your follow-up should be:

  • Short and Sweet: Get straight to the point. Remind them of your previous email and directly state what you're hoping to accomplish.

  • Personalized: Mention a detail from your first message or something new you've discovered about the recipient. Show that you're paying attention.

  • Value-Driven: Reinforce how you can solve their problem or contribute to their goals. It's about them, not you.

Here's the kicker—make sure you’re not pestering. If your first follow-up doesn’t get a response, wait a week or two before reaching out again. A good rule of thumb is to cap it at three follow-ups, spaced strategically apart, before gracefully bowing out.

Different techniques to consider include:

  • A/B Testing Subject Lines: Try different styles to see what resonates best.

  • Changing the Medium: Got their LinkedIn? A respectful message there might stand out.

  • Timing Is Everything: Sending follow-ups when your recipient is likely to be checking their inbox can improve your chances.

Adopting these practices is straightforward—just ensure you're always adding value with each interaction. And remember, the best route is the one that aligns with your unique voice and the relationship you hope to build with your recipient. Keep it professional, respectful, and aimed at creating a genuine connection.


Mastering the art of the cold email is within your reach. Remember, your initial message is the key to opening doors and building new connections. Keep it personalized, concise, and compelling. Your value proposition should be crystal clear and your call to action, impossible to ignore. Don't forget the power of a well-timed follow-up email to nudge your recipient in the right direction. It's all about adding value and staying professional. Stick to these strategies and you'll set the stage for successful collaborations and opportunities that can take your influence to new heights.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key elements of a successful cold email?

A successful cold email should have a persuasive subject line, a personalized opening, be concise, ask engaging questions, present a clear value proposition, and have a strong call to action (CTA).

How important is personalization in a cold email?

Personalization is crucial in a cold email as it makes the recipient feel recognized and increases the likelihood of a response.

What should a compelling introduction include?

A compelling introduction should include a personalized opening line and avoid focusing on the sender. It should quickly show understanding of the recipient's needs or interests.

What is a value proposition in cold emailing, and why is it important?

A value proposition in cold emailing is a clear statement that explains how your offering solves the recipient's problem or improves their situation. It's important because it differentiates you from competitors and can convince the recipient to engage further.

How should the call to action (CTA) be crafted in a cold email?

The CTA should use action-oriented language, be easy for the recipient to act upon, explicitly state the next steps, and align with their objectives. It needs to be visible and should stand out within the email.

What are the best practices for follow-up emails?

Follow-up emails should be brief, personalized, and add value. Keep the number of follow-ups to a cap of three and consider varying the approach with A/B testing or changing the communication medium.

Can over-promising in a cold email be harmful?

Yes, over-promising can damage credibility and should be avoided. It's crucial to be honest and realistic about what you can offer.

Explore your lead generation options

Book a call

Explore your lead generation options

Book a call

Explore your lead generation options

Book a call